Is bereavement different when a marriage breaks up than when there is no such bond?
Does it influence the fact that the couple has children or a mortgage in common?
What about the duration of the relationship?
This interesting issue is the subject of this this article published in La VanguardiaI have had the pleasure of contributing my professional point of view, both from my legal practice and from the reality we see on a daily basis in our office.
The unanimous conclusion, both for psychologists and other experts consulted and for those of us who see the breakup from the legal point of view, is identical: pain does not understand papers or legal ties, and has muchmore to do with emotional and personal aspects.
Grieving ‘divorce’ without getting married: same pain with or without papers
There are factors that can influence how we take the breakup. For example, our degree of dependence on the other person.
There are those who overcome this type of situation relatively easily in a natural way and those who show a less secure attachment, remaining anchored in the past for a longer period of time.
The spectrum of reactions is wide and also depends on our vital moment: for some people it may be more traumatic to divorce at an advanced age because they think it will be more difficult to find someone else; for others, maturity makes a potential breakup to be faced much more naturally and that this new vital space is even seen as an opportunity for growth.
Having a balanced life, with several pillars that support us, is not the same as having the opposite.
For example, job and economic stability, having family and friends, having a home of our own in which we can easily take refuge… are key elements that will serve as a network and will help our life not to fall apart.
What is true is that being married can complicate the logistics. After all, there will be a number of legal ties to break.
However, this does not have to be complex: the idea, as we always defend from Crespo Law, is to reach amicable and fair agreements, so that the judge must simply validate the previously agreed settlement agreement.
If there are no children, it is even possible to divorce before a notary.
It is also true that in case of marriage, the future projection of the couple may be clearer and, therefore, the breakup hurts more and is taken as a failure of a vital project.
However, many couples build a bond of the same entity without the need to get married; others, despite being married, never take their union so seriously, having clear from the beginning the possibility of breaking this legal bond at any time.
In short, the pain caused by a breakup, whatever its type, its duration… is something very personal that will depend on multiple factors, being the legal bond only one of them, and of relative importance.
As this report shows, there is an important social factor: saying “I got divorced” has a different weight and connotation than talking about a simple breakup, perhaps because we still think that a marriage is more serious than another type of union.
Nothing could be further from the truth, as practice shows us every day.
The presence of children: How does it influence the pain of the breakup?
Beyond the existence or not of marriage, the presence of children in common can be a determining factor in the degree of emotional difficulty of the breakup. After all, this will force us to maintain a bond for life, whether we like it or not.
The emotional breakup then becomes potentially much more complicated, and we will be forced to negotiate for a long time and to maintain a relationship that is at least cordial and respectful.How to achieve this? Ideally, a painless, mature and respectful breakup in which both parties take the time to negotiate and communicate in a healthy way.
If there is an imbalance in terms of willingness to close the relationship, it is advisable that the whole process is lived delicately and with emotional responsibility by both parties, creating the necessary space and time so that the most hurt party can assume the breakup and begin to negotiate its terms.
Almost always it is, at least, convenient and beneficial to go to therapy and/or family mediation to learn the necessary techniques to overcome the breakup and make it as clean and communicative as possible.
In other situations this possibility becomes imperative, especially in case of high conflict, infidelities and other situations that affect the process and generate extra pain. Cohabitation and economic elements also complicate things: it is not the same that each one has sufficient means and a home of their own than a situation of economic inequality in which one of the parties is forced to look for a new property in which to live without having sufficient means to get a living space adequate to their needs.
That is why it is so important not to give up our professional career and to maintain a healthy economy and a sufficient savings cushion, essential to protect ourselves against any eventuality.
The existence of joint debts, mortgages, shared assets and businesses… can also add complexity. In any case, as I explained for ‘La Vanguardia’, if there are minors involved, a breakup without marriage is the same as a divorce in terms of visitation, custody, alimony… The difference is that, in the procedural procedure, a divorce lawsuit will be filed if they were married or a lawsuit for termination of stable partnership if it was a domestic partnership.
On the other hand, unique to divorce proceedings is the fact that, if one of the spouses has been decompensated in his or her standard of living, he or she can claim a compensatory benefit, while in domestic partnerships it would be alimony, which cannot exceed a period of three years.
In the case of Catalonia, in order to be considered a domestic partner, the couple must be registered as such in the Registry of stable couples of Catalonia or, otherwise, they must be able to prove that they have been living together for more than two years.
If the couple has a child in common, it is automatically considered a common-law couple. Above all, I do not believe that a divorce makes it more difficult or cumbersome to separate: marriage is even more protective in cases where there is an economic imbalance, especially for women who give up paid work or take a reduced working day, as is the typical case of the housewife, because they are entitled to that compensatory pension, whether or not they have children. The complexity or not of this separation will be determined by the people more than by the procedure itself. Obviously, when there are children, things get more complicated, but here it does not matter whether you are married or not.
The greatest amount of conflict arises in custody disputes, especially if there are baby children, also for the education that you want to give them and for the use of the family home.
I even have very complicated divorces because they do not agree on the custody of the pet.
If you need help in any legal matter related to Family Law, contact our team of lawyers.

